Bad class-room memory
Last week, anti-racist educator, Sherene Razack was here at the law school doing a lecture on "How Is White Supremecy Embodied?: Sexualized Racial Violence at Abu Ghraib."
The room was set up in sort of a horseshoe shape and I was sitting kind of behind her, on her right. Sitting directly across from me, and behind Sherene on her left, was a black third-year law student, Alonzo. Because of the way the room was set up and where I was sitting, I had a much better view of Alonzo than of Sherene and this resulted in some bad class-room memories for me.
Sherene was speaking about lynching and sexual violence and the coalescence of power, control, racism, and patriarchy. Though I tried not to, I couldn’t help but see Alonzo and wonder about the experience of this presentation for him. I also felt like a Bystander in the midst of horror –especially when Sherene juxtaposed the words “caress” (such a beautiful word, onomatopoeic quality, almost tangible where you can hear, feel, sense the softness of caring touching) and then “castration” (which is violent and hurts and bleeds and is horror).
I wondered about Alonzo because this scene (the presentation about racial and sexualized violence in the presence of a black man) reminded me of a first-year history class where the Prof was talking about genocide in Canada and about the (deliberate!) distribution of smallpox infected blankets. This was totally NEW information to me and I was shocked and hurt with the casualness of the lecture. I wanted to scream that it couldn’t be true, that it had to be lie. I was also upset that no one-- not my mother or any other teachers--had prepared me for this.
Also when I think about it now, the juxtaposition of the words “distribution of blankets” (which is sharing and caring and warmth) and “smallpox infected” (which is greed and evil and death) is like using the words “caress” and “castration” in the same moment.
I know that the very best education is the education which is transformative and I often think about that in my Women’s Studies class. But I guess sometimes that “transformation” is so unsettling, so disturbing that it hurts and I think about my role in possibly hurting others.
I’m not suggesting that Alonzo was hurt (he is after all, a third-year law student and my guess is that he’s heard these stories before) but I’m reminded of the potential for pain in the class-room and for my responsibility in that. Didn’t Martin Luther King talk about the wounds that need to be lanced in order to let the poison out? I wonder how we as educators can lance those wounds in a way that doesn’t reproduce the terror but at the same time, unsettles us enough that we are transformed in the process. There’s a balancing act that has to be done and I think Sherene does that well.
So in the end, I’m left with lots to think about and I'm thankful for that. Maybe I can work some of these thoughts into an LLM paper or a lecture for my Women’s Studies class.
Painful though it is, I'm glad I remember.


